I got a request from Nelson (a BB reader) last week to make some homemade mac and cheese, and what a fantastic idea it was. I really need some mac and cheese in my life right about now. Of course, I added a good dose of broccoli to sort of balance out the meal and make sure I get my greens. ;) And I ended up using shells instead of macaroni because that’s what I had on hand. But if you don’t want broccoli shells and cheese, just leave out the broccoli, make everything else as directed, and you’ll have a good classic shells and cheese.
Originally posted 2/21/2011, updated 1-5-17
The Cheese Sauce Method
Making a cheese sauce can be a little bit intimidating at first, but give it a shot. Once you get the hang of it, it’s super easy. The thickening action of the roux is kinda like magic; very mysterious but you gotta learn to trust it. It will thicken.
What Kind of Cheese to Use
Sharp cheddar will give your mac the most flavor, but it also tends to “break” the easiest (turn lumpy in the sauce), so I usually use medium cheddar. I also added a little parmesan (another strong cheese) because after tasting the sauce I wanted it even cheesier! I despise a bland macaroni and cheese.
Why Add Hot Sauce?
I add just a little bit of hot sauce to my shells and cheese to add flavor but not really any heat. The hot sauce is completely optional. Many people add dry mustard which has a similar effect on the flavor. It just gives it a nice little zing of flavor on the back end. In the end, the cheese sauce is all about tasting and adjusting it to your liking. And really, who’s complaining about repeatedly tasting cheese sauce? No one.
Broccoli Shells and Cheese
- 8 oz. pasta ($0.55)
- 1/2 lb. frozen broccoli florets* ($0.90)
- 1/2 small onion, about 1/2 cup diced ($0.18)
- 3 Tbsp butter ($0.33)
- 3 Tbsp all-purpose flour ($0.03)
- 2.5 cups milk ($0.65)
- 2 cups shredded sharp cheddar ($1.89)
- 1/4 cup grated parmesan ($0.24)
- Salt and pepper to taste ($0.05)
- Bring a large pot of water to a boil for the pasta. Once boiling, add the pasta and continue to boil until the pasta is tender. Drain the pasta in a colander and set it aside until ready to use.
- Meanwhile, allow the broccoli to thaw. Once partially thawed, chop the florets into smaller, bite-sized pieces, and set them aside to fully thaw while you prepare the rest of the dish.
- While the pasta is cooking, begin the cheese sauce. Finely dice the onion and add it to a sauce pot with the butter. Cook the onion and butter over medium heat until the onions are softened (about 2-3 minutes).
- Add the flour to the butter and onion. The flour and butter will form a paste, or roux. Whisk the roux over medium heat for 1-2 minutes more taking care not to let it scorch. This slightly cooks the flour preventing the cheese sauce from having an overly flour or paste-like flavor.
- Whisk the milk into the roux until no lumps remain. Add some freshly cracked pepper to the sauce. Bring the mixture up to a simmer, stirring often (you may need to raise the heat just slightly). When the sauce reaches a simmer, it will begin to thicken. When it is thick enough to coat the back of a spoon, it’s time to add the cheese.
- Turn the burner off and whisk in the shredded cheddar, one handful at a time, until it is fully melted in. Next, stir in the grated Parmesan. Give the cheese sauce a taste and add salt, pepper, and hot sauce to taste.
- Once you have the cheese sauce seasoned to your liking, return the drained pasta to its large pot, add the chopped broccoli, and pour the cheese sauce over top. Stir until everything is combined and coated in the wonderfully cheesy sauce. Serve hot.
See how we calculate recipe costs here.
How to Make Broccoli Shells and Cheese – Step By Step Photos
Shred one 8oz. block of cheddar. Just be aware that sharp cheddar tends to “break”, or become lumpy, in cheese sauces a little bit easier than medium or mild cheddar. So, if you’re new to cheese sauces, start with a medium or mild cheddar.
Allow 1/2 lb. frozen broccoli florets to thaw. Once they are thawed enough to cut, chop them into smaller, bite-sized florets. Set them aside until ready to use (and to allow them to fully thaw).
Bring a large pot of water to a boil for the pasta. Once boiling, add 8oz. pasta shells and continue to boil until the shells are tender. Drain the shells in a colander.
While the pasta is cooking, prepare the cheese sauce. Finely dice 1/2 of a small onion (about 1/2 cup diced). Add the diced onion to a saucepot with 3 Tbsp butter. Cook the onion in the butter over medium heat until the onions are soft and transparent.
Then add 3 Tbsp all-purpose flour. Whisk and cook the flour with the butter and onions for about 2 minutes. This will slightly cook the flour and prevent the sauce from having a floury or glue-like flavor. This paste-like flour and butter mixture is called a “roux” and is what will thicken the cheese sauce.
Whisk in 2.5 cups whole milk until there are no lumps. Also, add some freshly cracked pepper (5-10 cranks of a pepper mill). Continue to cook and stir the milk until it comes up to a simmer, at which point it will begin to thicken.
When the sauce is thick enough to coat the back of a spoon, it is time to add the cheese.
TURN OFF THE HEAT, then stir in the cheddar, one hand full at a time, until it is fully melted into the sauce. It’s important to remove the sauce from the heat and melt in the cheese slowly to prevent the sauce from “breaking” or turning lumpy.
Once all the cheddar is melted in, stir in 1/4 cup grated Parmesan.
It’s now time to taste and season. I added a few dashes of hot sauce and just a little salt. You can use any hot sauce you like, Tobasco, Franks, Cholula, Sriracha, whatever. The idea is to add just enough to give the sauce a little zing, but no heat.
Once the sauce is seasoned to your liking, return the drained shells to the large pot, add the chopped broccoli, then pour the cheese sauce over top.
Stir everything together until that glorious cheese sauce is coating every inch of pasta and broccoli.
I mean, does it get any better than homemade Broccoli Shells and Cheese??
This was so delicious and so easy. I did use fresh broccoli, I steamed it.Boiled my shells then made my cheese sauce it was so good, a light cheese sauce. Perfect I followed this recipe couldn’t of been better. Thank you so much for this wonderful recipe.
This was SO good and simple. I opted for no broccoli this time (didn’t have any), and it was just the perfect comfort dinner. Didn’t take long to make at all and the sauce is cheesy and amazing.
I’m confused by the amount of sharp cheddar cheese that is supposed to be used. You have 8 oz, followed by 2 cups, but 2 cups would be 16 oz of cheese. Do we need 8 oz or 16 oz of shredded cheese?
Yes, this often confuses people. Liquid ingredients are measured in liquid ounces, solid ingredients are measured in weight ounces. One cup is 16 fluid ounces, but the weight in ounces depends on the density of the ingredient. 8 ounces (weight) of cheese is approximately 2 cups (volume) when shredded. You can cross-reference this with packages of shredded cheese you buy in the store, which are 8 ounces (weight) and labeled as being approximately two cups in volume. You need 8 ounces or approximately 2 cups of shredded cheese.
Do you have a conversion for making this recipe in a slow cooker or instapot?
Sorry we haven’t tested this recipe in either a slow cooker or a pressure cooker.
This was my first time making cheese sauce and it turned out great! I added some chopped garlic with the onions because we’re huge fans of it. The hot sauce was a great touch, wouldn’t have thought of that. I used Cholula.