Sriracha Pimento Cheese Spread

Pimento cheese purists step aside. This Sriracha Pimento Cheese Spread will not make you happy. But it makes me happy, and that is the number one criteria for my recipes. And if you’re the type that recoils at the thought of this strange orange spreadable cheese, just think of it as a cheese ball that’s not shaped into a ball. :) It’s the same concept. Cheese mixed with yummy stuff that you can dip, spread, or enjoy any way you like. It’s great for parties (hello holidays and football!) and it’s great to just keep in your fridge for quick sandwiches or snacks.

I decided to make a Sriracha Pimento Cheese spread after I had visions of a melty grilled cheese sandwich with gooey cheese and bright red sriracha oozing out the side (yeah, cheese cravings cause really vivid mental images for me, LOL). That mental image snowballed into Pimento Cheese Spread spiked with sriracha and a few green onions to brighten things up.

Adding sriracha to pimento cheese spread is awesome because it not only adds heat, but it adds a hint of garlic flavor, a little tanginess from vinegar, and very, very slight sweetness. I had a jar of fire roasted peppers in my pantry for-ev-er, so I used those instead of pimentos, which are made from cherry peppers and are slightly sweeter. The fire roasted peppers were still a nice sweet contrast to the cheese and sriracha, and they added a wonderful hint of smoky flavor. PERFECT.

I think pretzels are my favorite thing to dip into this cheese, but celery might be my second favorite. The fresh watery crispness of celery is a wonderful palate cleanser and contrast to the heavy spread. Pimento cheese also makes a great quick sandwich, and this morning I used it in my egg quesadilla! I’d love to hear your favorite way to eat pimento cheese spread in the comments below!

Sriracha Pimento Cheese

This Sriracha Pimento Cheese Spread is a rich, smoky, spicy spread with just a hint of sweetness from roasted red peppers! BudgetBytes.com

This Sriracha Pimento Cheese Spread is a rich, smoky, spicy spread with just a hint of sweetness from roasted red peppers! BudgetBytes.com
5 from 3 votes
Print

Sriracha Pimento Cheese Spread

This Sriracha Pimento Cheese Spread is a rich, smoky, spicy spread with just a hint of sweetness from roasted red peppers! 

Total Cost $4.31 recipe / $0.72 serving
Prep Time 15 minutes
Total Time 15 minutes
Servings 6 1/2 cup each

Ingredients

  • 8 oz extra sharp cheddar, shredded* $1.77
  • 4 oz cream cheese, room temperature $0.60
  • 1/2 cup mayonnaise $0.56
  • 3 Tbsp sriracha (or to taste) $0.27
  • 1 cup diced roasted red peppers $1.00
  • 1 green onion $0.11

Instructions

  1. Add the shredded cheddar, cream cheese, mayonnaise, and 1 Tbsp sriracha to a large bowl.

  2. Finely dice the roasted red peppers and finely chop the green onion. Add both to the bowl with the other ingredients. Use a hand mixer to combine the mixture until the cream cheese is well incorporated (the mixture will still be lumpy because of the shredded cheese and diced peppers).

  3. Taste the mixture and add more sriracha to your liking. I added a total of 3 Tbsp sriracha. Keep in mind that the spiciness will increase slightly as the mixture refrigerates.

  4. Serve immediately, or refrigerate until ready to eat. The mixture will keep in the refrigerator for 4-5 days.

Recipe Notes

*I highly suggest shredding your own cheese for this instead of buying pre-shredded. The starchy coating on pre-shredded cheese will prevent the cheese from combining properly in the spread.

This Sriracha Pimento Cheese Spread is a rich, smoky, spicy spread with just a hint of sweetness from roasted red peppers! BudgetBytes.com

Step by Step Photos

Cheddar Cream Cheese Mayonnaise Sriracha

Star by shredding one 8oz. block of extra sharp cheddar cheese. Add it to a large bowl with 4oz. room temperature cream cheese, 1/2 cup mayonnaise, and 1 Tbsp sriracha (you can add more to your liking later, but start with just 1 Tbsp). 

Fire Roasted Red Peppers

You’ll need about 1 cup of finely diced roasted red peppers. In this 12 oz. jar from Trader Joes there were two whole peppers. I used one. Dice it up into super small pieces. Also finely chop one green onion.

Sriracha Pimento Cheese Spread Ingredients

Add the diced peppers and chopped green onion to the bowl with the cheese, mayo, and sriracha.

Mixed Sriracha Pimento Cheese Spread

Use a hand mixer to blend the ingredients until the cream cheese is fully incorporated. Taste the mixture and add more sriracha to your liking. I ended up using THREE tablespoons total. Keep in mind that it will get a little bit more spicy as it sits in the fridge. If you don’t have a hand mixer you can use a food process, a regular stand mixer, or even just a fork and a lot of elbow grease. :)

This Sriracha Pimento Cheese Spread is a rich, smoky, spicy spread with just a hint of sweetness from roasted red peppers! BudgetBytes.com

Serve the Sriracha Pimento Cheese Spread with plenty of crunchies for dipping! You can serve it immediately, or refrigerate it until you’re ready to eat. 🧀